I would rate the Superman Films as follows.
Superman:The Movie
Man Of Steel
Superman II
Batman vs Superman
Justice League The Snyder Cut
Superman Returns
Superman (Jose!) II The Donner Cut
Superman III
Superman IV
And for the record, I too live in NA, and I don’t think I have ever gotten a scratched disc period. And I buy pretty much exclusively from Amazon and Best Buy.
Weird that you’re experiencing this problem. So frustrating