Blu-ray Review Rogue One: A Star Wars Story Blu-ray Review (1 Viewer)

[Matt Hough]

Matt Hough

Rogue One: A Star Wars Story Blu-ray Review

For those (like me) who were extremely dissatisfied with the three prequel movies which now exist as Episodes 1, 2, and 3, Rogue One feels like the prequel that Star Wars: A New Hope always deserved.

[review]
Read more.

 

[Johnny Angell]

Is there a consensus on whether BB or Target has the best extras for the 3D version? It would appear the only thing special about the the BB versions is the steel book. Target does have exclusive content.

 

[Josh Steinberg]

Is there a consensus on whether BB or Target has the best extras for the 3D version?

For extras, definitely Target. The Best Buy version has all of the same extras that appear on the standard edition, with the addition of the 3D disc. Only the Target version includes additional exclusive bonus features in addition to the 3D disc.

 

[dpippel]

Be aware that Target's exclusive content is typically only available via streaming. There's no extra disc.

 

[Josh Steinberg]

Be aware that Target's exclusive content is typically only available via streaming. There's no extra disc.

That's sometimes true, but in this instance, they specifically noted that the extra content will be on an included bonus DVD disc.

From the website description: "Only at Target: Collectible packaging with interchangeable covers + exclusive content on bonus disc!"

The Target exclusive "Star Trek Beyond" release from last year also included that bonus material on an additional disc.

 

[dpippel]

Thanks Josh, I missed that on this release. Since the cover only states "Exclusive Content" I figured it was the usual BS and didn't dig any further.

 

[Johnny Angell]

Be aware that Target's exclusive content is typically only available via streaming. There's no extra disc.

That means the content could disappear at any time and that sucks.

That's sometimes true, but in this instance, they specifically noted that the extra content will be on an included bonus DVD disc.

From the website description: "Only at Target: Collectible packaging with interchangeable covers + exclusive content on bonus disc!"

The Target exclusive "Star Trek Beyond" release from last year also included that bonus material on an additional disc.

The extra material is only on a dvd, not a blu ray? That sucks too. Is the content usually worth choosing Target over BB?

 

[Josh Steinberg]

The extra material is only on a dvd, not a blu ray? That sucks too. Is the content usually worth choosing Target over BB?

The price is about the same on the Target and Best Buy releases, so your only choice is really - do you want more bonus features or not? The Best Buy set doesn't have any exclusive bonus content, just the same as on the regular release.

I never care about retail exclusive packaging. I only care about content on disc. Target's version, which includes extra bonus content, is of more value to me than Best Buy's, which does not. YMMV.

 

[Carabimero]

I was disappointed that the Dr. Strange Target extra was an online link. If RO has the Target extra on the disc, I'm in.

 

[Josh Steinberg]

I was disappointed that the Dr. Strange Target extra was an online link. If RO has the Target extra on the disc, I'm in.

The press release said it will be on a DVD disc.

 

[Mike Frezon]

Matt:

Thanks for the review!

I'm probably one of the few forum members who did NOT get to the theater to see Rogue One. It's comforting to know that with 5 of 5 rankings on audio and video I'll be getting a solid home video presentation to really enjoy this on my gear.

It looks like the Amazon/Disney spat will force me into a Target or Wal-Mart to pick up this release.

Count me among those who are surprised they didn't resolve their differences before this week.

 

[David Norman]

Target 3D has the extra bonus DVD, but best guess is that it's only 10+ minutes of material. I actually like Target's package better than Walmart 2D, the std 2D, or BBY steelbook so it was an easy choice esp with the extra preorder $5 GC offer. No theater for me either.

If they don;t settle quickly this may be in for the long haul -- Pinocchio, Doctor Strange, Moana and now Rogue One. There;s just nothing to force their hand for many months. Of course they've already lost all the preorders and no 3D item. My Target 3D just shipped tonight so should be here by Monday night.

Bambi appears to be a June Release now, but the next big Disney home video will certainly be BatB (2017) then leading candidate Lion King Signature for holiday season plus the summer Disney movie is (Cars3, Pirates 5, Guardians of the Galaxy). I was thinking BATB would be a Fall release, but timing say Summer makes more sense bases on teh last couple years.

 

[Johnny Angell]

The price is about the same on the Target and Best Buy releases.

As of yesterday the BB steel case was $3 less than Target.

 

[Osato]

The extra target content is only 10 minutes long.
I will be picking up my copy from Barnes & Noble's. As I have a gift card there.
Can't wait for Tuesday!

 

[Todd H]

Matt:

It looks like the Amazon/Disney spat will force me into a Target or Wal-Mart to pick up this release.

Same here. Guess Amazon doesn't want my money.

 

[Stephen_J_H]

Looks like it'll be Best Buy for Canadians if you want 3D.

 

[WillG]

Not sure 10 min is worth an extra 3 bucks. Will Target price match Best Buy?

 

[dpippel]

On a retailer-exclusive title? I seriously doubt it.

 

[Carabimero]

Does anyone have any of the particulars of the beef between Disney and Amazon?

 

[Robert Crawford]

Does anyone have any of the particulars of the beef between Disney and Amazon?

It's always about money, one way or another.