Winston T. Boogie
Senior HTF Member
The controversy or debate is over who actually directed the movie. Rumor has it that Steven Spielberg- forgive the pun- ghost directed the movie for Tobe Hooper. Spielberg completely denies that. Personally, I think Spielberg helped out when needed or he made suggestions that Hooper definitely followed (Hooper would have been stupid to not listen to Spielberg since he had lots of experience with special effects and Hooper had none) but overall, Hooper has been robbed of credit by fans.
I think the deal was Spielberg had nothing to do with directing but he sort of micromanaged the project because he had badly wanted to direct it. Due to his schedule at the time he had to pick a film to give up directing and he chose to give up Poltergeist. Hooper was the one and only director on the film but was very much under Spielberg's thumb.