haineshisway
Senior HTF Member
Before I comment, John, are you of the opinion that most of the Fox transfers heretofore have a blue push?
I watched this last night and I'm very disappointed. I don't think there's a brown push as such. I think the transfer is simply too dark. It's not as extreme as in the Blu-ray disc of the King Vidor/ Audrey Hepburn War And Peace but it's enough to subdue all the colors. I hope that a European boutique label like Arrow will take this on and try to do it better, as happened with The Quiet Man.I agree with you about their accuracy. And that's my problem with Three Coins - it's almost like they decided to get even with the blue brigade and do a browner transfer. The skin tones are weird to me and while there certainly is blue it's not as deep as it should be and nothing pops. Now, maybe it's just that the Three Coins negative is problematic, which is probably the case. But then that doesn't explain the not quite right Bedazzled.
Robin9, did I read your post correctly?I watched this last night and I'm very disappointed. I don't think there's a brown push as such. I think the transfer is simply too dark. It's not as extreme as in the Blu-ray disc of the King Vidor/ Audrey Hepburn War And Peace but it's enough to subdue all the colors. I hope that a European boutique label like Arrow will take this on and try to do it better, as happened with The Quiet Man.
I have all three releases of "The Quiet Man" on Blu-ray. The first Olive release of 01-22-13 followed by the MOC release of 11-23-15 and finally the Olive Signature release of 10-25-16. I seriously doubt you can tell the difference between the MOC and the last Olive Signature releases.Robin9, did I read your post correctly?
Are you saying that you've been able to compare both the Masters of Cinema and Olive Signature editions of "The Quiet Man"?
If so, please fill us in on those differences, as I was under the impression that they were equal. Will buy MoC if it's better.
Correct. My point was that the first Olive disc was severely criticized and the U.K. disc showed what was wrong. Olive made amends with their second disc.I have all three releases of "The Quiet Man" on Blu-ray. The first Olive release of 01-22-13 followed by the MOC release of 11-23-15 and finally the Olive Signature release of 10-25-16. I seriously doubt you can tell the difference between the MOC and the last Olive Signature releases.
I agree with you about their accuracy. And that's my problem with Three Coins - it's almost like they decided to get even with the blue brigade and do a browner transfer. The skin tones are weird to me and while there certainly is blue it's not as deep as it should be and nothing pops. Now, maybe it's just that the Three Coins negative is problematic, which is probably the case. But then that doesn't explain the not quite right Bedazzled.
That's interesting and suggests that it should be possible for another label to obtain better results.'3 Coins' was a few weeks ago shown on UK BBC TV in HD. The picture quality was truly excellent with wonderful colors and good sound.
The TT release which I have is not hardly as good so I was disappointed and in comparison to the BBC HD showing it resembles DVD quality.
Did you notice a big black blob in the dark black of the scene when Melvin is saving Howard?Well, you know I did. Not a great transfer.
'3 Coins' was a few weeks ago shown on UK BBC TV in HD. The picture quality was truly excellent with wonderful colors and good sound.
The TT release which I have is not hardly as good so I was disappointed and in comparison to the BBC HD showing it resembles DVD quality.
I recommend that you also do what I did and compare the colors and the brightness of the DVD against the Blu-ray disc. To my eyes, the DVD gets it about right while the Blu-ray disc is too dark. I'd be interested in your opinions about both comparisons.That's an interesting comment because I'm afraid I didn't think that BBC broadcast of "Three Coins in the Fountain" which I have on my hard drive and watched on my 4K 60" LG was very good. For one thing, it's far too dark. For instance, when Maggie McNamara is in Rome station at the beginning of the film, the interior station area behind her can barely be made out, being dark and obscured, compared to the DVD where everything can be clearly seen. The color was better than the DVD but was still rather dull. I have the TT on order so will be interested in doing a comparison, to see if I agree with you that the TT is even worse!
'3 Coins' was a few weeks ago shown on UK BBC TV in HD. The picture quality was truly excellent with wonderful colors and good sound.
The TT release which I have is not hardly as good so I was disappointed and in comparison to the BBC HD showing it resembles DVD quality.