The vast majority of commentaries get turned off after 20-30 minutes tops. The one I've enjoyed most that was listened to all the way through is:
Maureen O'Hara on Miracle on 34th Street.
Maureen O'Hara is in much better form on THE BLACK SWAN commentary, where she's guided by the late, great Rudy Behlmer.
I’ve re-listened to the Toy Story commentaries, which are good and have a lot of technical and making info.
That’s effectively what I do now: rip the commentary track from the blu-ray, convert to an MP3, and listen on my iPhone on the go.When we get to road trip season this summer, I may copy all the Pixar commentaries to tape and listen to them in order! I've heard all of them but it'd be nice to listen again!
That’s effectively what I do now: rip the commentary track from the blu-ray, convert to an MP3, and listen on my iPhone on the go.
I'm generally not a fan of commentaries for many of the reasons listed above - I'd rather watch a good making-of documentary any day - but the commentary on the Anchor Bay DVD of The Ipcress File with director Sidney J. Furie and editor Peter Hunt was excellent. They were not only informative, but very honest, speaking openly about who they enjoyed working with and who was difficult.
Nothing wrong with it if it works for you. I just haven’t had a tape player in car or at home for years.I've transferred commentaries to tape since the 90s. Yes, I know it's old school and I could put them on my phone, but I'm content with this method!
I've just listened to too many which are mostly dead air or the participants describing what's happening on screen.Commentaries are my favorite bonus feature. Sure, some of them are awful, but most are decent, and many are very good to excellent.
You potentially get a lot more information from a commentary than from a "making of" piece since the running time goes so much longer!
I agree and especially on "Crime Wave" as he and James Ellroy were definitely having some drinks during that commentary.Any Eddie Muller commentary. "Cry of The City" is great. Loved "Crime Wave"...the commentary he did with James Ellroy...truly an experience. (Ellroy seems crazy, in a pleasant sort of way).
He can turn even the most modest noir into something rich and fascinating.
Runner up: Liza Minnelli on "The Band Wagon." Like she's next to you on the sofa, just chatting about the movie...
Any Eddie Muller commentary. "Cry of The City" is great. Loved "Crime Wave"...the commentary he did with James Ellroy...truly an experience. (Ellroy seems crazy, in a pleasant sort of way).
He can turn even the most modest noir into something rich and fascinating.
Runner up: Liza Minnelli on "The Band Wagon." Like she's next to you on the sofa, just chatting about the movie...
I think Ellroy is sober. It's probably just his being crazy that you're hearing.I agree and especially on "Crime Wave" as he and James Ellroy were definitely having some drinks during that commentary.
Was he sober back in 2006/2007 when that commentary was recorded? If he was sober then he's definitely one crazy dude as both of them had me cracking up during much of the commentary. The movie "Crime Wave" was filmed mostly out in actual LA locations and some of those locations like Bunker Hill doesn't exist today.I think Ellroy is sober. It's probably just his being crazy that you're hearing.
Have you managed to listen to other Ronald Haver commentaries on old Criterion laserdiscs? His were really good (King Kong, Wizard Of Oz, Casablanca). Very well-prepared and informative, unlike most commentary tracks nowadays, which seem to consist of people hanging around and reacting (or even, not reacting). I heard Alan Parker's old commentary on the 4K UHD of Angel Heart - terrible. He just sat there saying how long ago it was since he had seen the film and spent long stretches in complete silence, just enjoying himself!
He may have fallen off the wagon at points but I think he quit drinking when he decided to seriously focus on being a writer in the late 70's. Crazy or drunk, the dude is a riot and an amazing writer.Was he sober back in 2006/2007 when that commentary was recorded? If he was sober then he's definitely one crazy dude as both of them had me cracking up during much of the commentary. The movie "Crime Wave" was filmed mostly out in actual LA locations and some of those locations like Bunker Hill doesn't exist today.