Jeffrey D
Senior HTF Member
- Joined
- Oct 15, 2018
- Messages
- 5,252
- Real Name
- Jeffrey D Hanawalt
Another track I like is the director/writer commentary for Rounders. Norton is entertaining both in the film, and on the
track.
track.
Yes director Jack Sholder was pretty frank on the track, not only about Nouri, but about other things- there was a scene where Miller leaves his hospital room, and a doctor and nurse was involved in the scene. Sholder really criticized their acting abilities.The Hidden (1987) has a commentary that I like. It’s been a long time since I head it. I think it was the director doing it. What stands out in my mind was the director wondering while Michael Nouri wasn’t a big star. He had the looks and the talent. Then while working with him, he discovered why: he’s an asshole and extremely difficult to work with. I’ve never heard such explicit criticism on a commentary before. Usually it’s “we were do lucky to get this guy.”
Yeah, I remember that. Something about not having the money to hire real actors.Yes director Jack Sholder was pretty frank on the track, not only about Nouri, but about other things- there was a scene where Miller leaves his hospital room, and a doctor and nurse was involved in the scene. Sholder really criticized their acting abilities.
That’s one of those commentaries that changed my view of the film. I didn’t understand the movie when I wanted it, on DVD delivered in Netflix envelope, viewed on a 27” CRT, natch. But listening to the commentary revealed the movie to me and significantly changed my opinion of it.I think maybe my favorite commentary is Anthony Minghella on The Talented Mr. Ripley. He goes deep into the artistic aspects, the most memorable being the process of adapting the novel into a screenplay.
Yes Garry Marshall’s commentary for Pretty Woman is a really good one. He did Tracks for both the anamorphic and non-anamorphic DVD release- his first narration on the non-I think maybe my favorite commentary is Anthony Minghella on The Talented Mr. Ripley. He goes deep into the artistic aspects, the most memorable being the process of adapting the novel into a screenplay. (Creative discussions are always more interesting to me than gossip or walking down Memory Lane. A particularly annoying example of the latter was Anne Heche's contributions to the Psycho (1998) commentary.)
I find Garry Marshall's commentaries to be very entertaining and informative--at least those that I've heard (Pretty Woman and Runaway Bride). He sounds like he was a very warm and generous man. (And he was so hilarious. I absolutely loved watching him play the network president on Murphy Brown, and enjoyed a talk he gave at Northwestern University many years ago.)
Someone whose commentaries I cannot get excited about is Marian Keane, who appears on several Criterion discs. It seems she reads a bit too much into some things, and comes off as the kind of academic who takes great pride in coming up with unique theories and interpretations of films.
I think maybe my favorite commentary is Anthony Minghella on The Talented Mr. Ripley. He goes deep into the artistic aspects, the most memorable being the process of adapting the novel into a screenplay. (Creative discussions are always more interesting to me than gossip or walking down Memory Lane. A particularly annoying example of the latter was Anne Heche's contributions to the Psycho (1998) commentary.)
I find Garry Marshall's commentaries to be very entertaining and informative--at least those that I've heard (Pretty Woman and Runaway Bride). He sounds like he was a very warm and generous man. (And he was so hilarious. I absolutely loved watching him play the network president on Murphy Brown, and enjoyed a talk he gave at Northwestern University many years ago.)
Someone whose commentaries I cannot get excited about is Marian Keane, who appears on several Criterion discs. It seems she reads a bit too much into some things, and comes off as the kind of academic who takes great pride in coming up with unique theories and interpretations of films.
I’m rewatching TV series Futurama and relistening to the commentaries. They are so great! They give great details on the show’s creation, the performers, secrets embedded for fans, the animation design. It’s everything I want in a commentary.
Yes Garry Marshall’s commentary for Pretty Woman is a really good one. He did Tracks for both the anamorphic and non-anamorphic DVD release- his first narration on the non-
anamorphic release was a little better.
Ah- I didn’t know the non-anamorphic commentary was a carry-over from laserdisc.Technically, that was for a laserdisc!
Ah- I didn’t know the non-anamorphic commentary was a carry-over from laserdisc.
Thanks.
Yes his commentaries aren’t some of the better ones. He did give a few interesting tidbits onEasier to pick the worst ones ……..The Great William Friedkin who thinks he recording a track for the blind
John Frankenheimer.Who directed the original Manchurian Candiate? I recall that one being good.
Yes his commentaries aren’t some of the better ones. He did give a few interesting tidbits on
The French Connection track though (he said there were unplanned accidents during the elevated train chase due to not enough security personnel to lock down the location).