Peter Rohlfs
Second Unit
DittoI was hoping for more Marilyn Monroe.
DittoI was hoping for more Marilyn Monroe.
Maltin is a movie reviewer and not a film critic (there is a difference) and he also gave one and a half stars to the original Blade Runner (which makes it equal to Genghis Khan in Maltin's opinion) and a mere two stars to Taxi Driver. For what it's worth
For what it's worth, Leonard Maltin gives it one and 1/2 stars and calls it "Laughable epic with gross miscasting and juvenile script." I guess none of us are 14 anymore. Cheers~~
I was about the same age as Alan when I saw Genghis Khan and loved every minute of it. I have revisited it many times over the years and have always had fun with it. The music score is outstanding. I never imagined seeing this on Blu- thank you TT.
I am unfamiliar with Huang Shi but may give it a try.
Holy Cow !!! Maltin gave "Taxi Driver" only 2 stars? Huh? What? This has to be a case of personal tastes; coming from the guy who got the brilliant "Disney Treasures" going and - back in the 70's - wrote an excellent and comprehensive book on comedy shorts. That's why its good to know the tastes of the critic/movie reviewer; as this it makes it easier to discern when dealing with your own tastes. But, with that said, what are the additional attributes (besides its music) that make Genghis Khan noteworthy in being a TT release? This is not at all a sarcasm; it's only a case of my not being familiar with the film, at all.Maltin is a movie reviewer and not a film critic (there is a difference) and he also gave one and a half stars to the original Blade Runner (which makes it equal to Genghis Khan in Maltin's opinion) and a mere two stars to Taxi Driver. For what it's worth
Holy Cow !!! Maltin gave "Taxi Driver" only 2 stars? Huh? What? This has to be a case of personal tastes; coming from the guy who got the brilliant "Disney Treasures" going and - back in the 70's - wrote an excellent and comprehensive book on comedy shorts. That's why its good to know the tastes of the critic/movie reviewer; as this it makes it easier to discern when dealing with your own tastes. But, with that said, what are the additional attributes (besides its music) that make Genghis Khan noteworthy in being a TT release? This is not at all a sarcasm; it's only a case of my not being familiar with the film, at all.
Let me put in my two cents for Twilight Time upgrades of THIEF OF BAGDAD(1939)... colors that would pop off the screen as well as a great Miklos Rozsa score
I have issues only with Pauline Kael and had wished that once in her own career she knew what it was like to be washed away for 14 years by a single giant wave. A "moderately enough" on "Genghis Khan" in conjunction to my thorough enjoyment of "Santa Vittoria" works enough for me; as I don't even have the DVD and will delve into a purchase in order to expand my knowledge of another composer and his ways of scoring of the film.I enjoy Genghis Khan moderately enough to own it on DVD but not enough to upgrade to blu ray though if it pops up at $9.99 at some TT sale I might bite as I did with Secret Of Santa Vittoria, another film I like well enough but don't love. So I'm not the one to come to Khan's defense . I merely responded with that tidbit to show that Matlin's tastes are not definitive (even he calls them opinions). Personally, I think he's pretty much a hack but hey, that's just me. Not as bad as Rex Reed (who is?) but pretty low on the critical scale for me. I prefer real critics like Pauline Kael, Andrew Sarris, Roger Ebert and Manohla Dargis which is not to say I take their word as gospel either but at least I respect their opinions even if I don't agree with them (which I often don't). I would imagine TT decided to release Genghis Khan because the film elements are in good shape and the film does have a cult following of sorts.
I have issues only with Pauline Kael and had wished that once in her own career she knew what it was like to be washed away for 14 years by a single giant wave. A "moderately enough" on "Genghis Khan" in conjunction to my thorough enjoyment of "Santa Vittoria" works enough for me; as I don't even have the DVD and will delve into a purchase in order to expand my knowledge of another composer and his ways of scoring of the film.
Nice write-up Thomas T. Or is that Thomas TT?
I absolutely love Ryan's Daughter and disagreed with Kael's appraisal of it.[...]
No Down Payment, yes; but did it arrive C.O.D.?Now if you'll excuse me, my blu ray of TT's No Down Payment arrived in today's mail [...]
I think Ryan's Daughter is a good film, but one of Lean's lesser works. It's very scale and scope seem to work against the story somehow. But I think it's poor reception had less to do with the quality of the film and more to do with the fact that it was very much out of sync with the times when it was released.I absolutely love Ryan's Daughter and disagreed with Kael's appraisal of it. But as much as I admire David Lean, c'mon, negative reviews are part of the game when you're a film maker so it's unfair to blame his 14 year absence on Kael's so called "power".
I think Ryan's Daughter is a good film, but one of Lean's lesser works. It's very scale and scope seem to work against the story somehow. But I think it's poor reception had less to do with the quality of the film and more to do with the fact that it was very much out of sync with the times when it was released.
Let me say first that I love TLT's transfers. My problem is with their choice of film. I know there are many of you that think the '70's had the best films and others who feel that noir is all! Let me put in my two cents for Twilight Time upgrades of THIEF OF BAGDAD(1939) and SHOWBOAT (1936). The former has colors that would pop off the screen as well as a great Miklos Rozsa score, and the latter in glorious black and white looking like the most beautiful of woodcuts with superlative direction by James Whale and wonderful performances by Paul Robson and Hattie McDaniel. A few cringeworthy racist moments but all in all a magnificent work. P.S. And since Fox seems to be a favorite, how about a new print of CARMEN JONES?
For what it's worth, Leonard Maltin gives it one and 1/2 stars and calls it "Laughable epic with gross miscasting and juvenile script." I guess none of us are 14 anymore. Cheers~~